The Great London Space Race: Combi Boiler vs. Hot Water Tank; Which is Right for Your Home?

Another Image

The Great London Space Race

For decades, the central heating setup in a typical London house was a given. A big, bulky boiler somewhere, a copper-coloured hot water cylinder in an airing cupboard, and a massive cold water tank taking up half the loft. It was a system that took up a huge amount of valuable space.

Then came the Combi boiler, and it changed everything. This compact, all-in-one unit promised to do away with the tanks and provide instant hot water on demand. It’s been a revolution, and for millions of London flats and smaller homes, it’s the undisputed champion.

But is it always the right choice? As our homes have changed and our demands for high-performance hot water have grown, the debate is back on. When you’re looking to upgrade your heating system, you face a crucial choice: do you go for the space-saving convenience of a Combi, or the powerful performance of a modern hot water tank?

As an engineer who designs systems for all types of London properties, from studio flats to five-bedroom family homes, the answer depends entirely on three things: your property, your family, and your lifestyle.

The Contenders

Let’s meet the two modern champions of home heating.

• The Combi (Combination) Boiler: A single unit that heats your radiators and provides hot water instantly by heating mains water as it passes through the boiler. There are no tanks.
• The System Boiler with an Unvented Cylinder: A two-part system. A powerful boiler heats the central heating, and also heats water that is then stored under high pressure in a super-insulated hot water cylinder (the modern, high-performance version of the old copper tank).

Round 1: The Battle for Space

In London, every square foot is precious. This is the Combi boiler’s home turf.

• The Combi’s Advantage: By removing the need for a hot water cylinder, a Combi boiler can free up a whole airing cupboard. This is a huge win in a flat or a small terrace, where that space can be converted into a wardrobe, a small office nook, or extra storage. If space is your absolute priority, the Combi often wins by a knockout.
• The Cylinder’s Position: An unvented cylinder still needs a home. While modern cylinders are sleek and highly insulated, they are still a significant size, typically housed in a cupboard. However, you do gain all your loft space back, as a system boiler doesn’t need the big cold water tank.

Winner: The Combi Boiler

Round 2: The Hot Water Performance Test

This is where the fight gets interesting. It’s not about which one provides hotter water, but how much it can provide at once.

• The Combi’s Performance: A Combi is like a sprinter. It gives you hot water instantly, and it will never run out. The downside is its flow rate. A Combi’s power is split between all the hot taps that are open. If you’re having a shower and someone turns on the hot tap in the kitchen, you will notice a drop in pressure and temperature. It’s great for one-bathroom homes, but can struggle with the demands of a busy family.
• The Cylinder’s Performance: An unvented cylinder is like a weightlifter. It has a huge store of high-pressure hot water ready to go. You can have two or even three powerful showers running in different bathrooms at the same time, with no drop in performance. It delivers a powerful, high-flow rate that a Combi simply cannot match. The downside? If you use up all the stored water, you have to wait for it to reheat (though modern cylinders are very quick to recover).

Winner: The System Boiler with Unvented Cylinder

Round 3: The London Factor – Mains Water Pressure

This is a crucial consideration, especially in older London properties.

• The Combi’s Dependency: A Combi boiler’s performance is entirely dependent on the pressure of the cold water main coming into your property. If you have poor incoming pressure, your Combi’s hot water flow rate will also be poor. A powerful Combi on a weak main is like putting a Ferrari engine in a Fiat Panda.
• The Cylinder’s Advantage: An unvented cylinder stores water at mains pressure, but because it acts as a buffer, it can deliver a consistently powerful flow even if the incoming main isn’t spectacular.

A good engineer will always measure your home’s incoming water pressure and flow rate before recommending a system.

The Engineer’s Verdict: Which One is Right for YOU?

Forget the marketing. Let’s make this simple. Run through this checklist:

• You should choose a Combi Boiler if:
  • You live in a flat or a house with only one bathroom.
  • Space-saving is your number one priority.
  • You have good to excellent mains water pressure.
  • You live in a small household where multiple hot taps are rarely used at the same time.
• You should choose a System Boiler with an Unvented Cylinder if:
  • You have two or more bathrooms that are likely to be used at the same time.
  • You have powerful “rain” showers or body jets that demand a high flow rate.
  • You have a larger family with a high demand for hot water.
  • You have the space (e.g., an airing cupboard) to house the cylinder.

The choice is no longer about “old vs. new.” It’s about “convenience vs. power.” Both are brilliant, modern, and efficient systems. The key is to choose the one that is engineered to fit your home and your lifestyle, not the other way around.

Confused about which system is right for your London home? Contact Boiler Repairs R US for a free home survey. We’ll test your water pressure, assess your needs, and provide an honest, expert recommendation on the best heating solution for you.

---